Short answer: there are pros and cons to each, and it is ultimately up to you. Electric is easier on a beginner’s fingers. Acoustic builds a more percussive, rhythmic approach, which I believe is the most important skill no matter the genre.
The honest tradeoff
There are pros and cons to each. The electric guitar is certainly easier on a beginner player’s fingers. The acoustic guitar lends itself to a more percussive, rhythmic approach, which I believe is the most important skill no matter the genre.
My own experience
I started on electric guitar first, and I did not really see my skills improve rapidly until I got an acoustic. That is one person’s path, not a rule, but it is why I lean toward getting an acoustic in your hands early if you can.
Electric guitar
- Lighter strings and a lower action, so pressing chords hurts less at the start.
- Needs an amplifier (or a headphone amp), which adds cost.
- The natural choice if rock, blues or lead playing is your goal.
Acoustic guitar
- Heavier strings and more finger strength needed, so the first few weeks can be sore.
- No amp, no cables. Pick it up and play anywhere.
- Rewards strong rhythm and strumming, and suits singer-songwriter and campfire music well.
How to choose
- Start with the music. What do you actually want to play? Buy the instrument that fits that.
- Budget for the whole setup. An electric needs an amp. An acoustic is a single purchase.
- Do not agonize. The skills transfer. What you learn on one carries over to the other.
Bottom line, it is totally up to the individual. If you are not sure which fits your goals, ask me before you buy anything. Start on the lessons page or send a message.
Want a plan built around your songs?
One-on-one online lessons over Zoom, ages 10 and up, from $45. 246 five-star reviews.
Book Your First Lesson ↗︎Quick answers
Is electric guitar easier than acoustic for beginners?
Electric guitars are easier on beginner fingers because of lighter strings and lower action. Acoustics take more finger strength at first but build a strong rhythmic foundation.
Should a beginner start on acoustic or electric guitar?
Start with the instrument that fits the music you want to play. If you are unsure, an acoustic is a single purchase and builds rhythm, while an electric is gentler on your fingers but needs an amp.
Can I switch from acoustic to electric later?
Yes. The core skills, such as chords, rhythm and fretting, carry over between the two, so you are not starting over.